Priced on the same night, 2026-10-25: JW Marriott New Orleans is $51 a night less. They are 309 metres apart.
Book takes you to the exact room at that rate on HotelDupe's booking partner. Confirmation arrives by email; manage or cancel any time from Find your booking.
Book the Roosevelt if you want the grand New Orleans hotel experience: the spa, pet-friendly rooms, hot tub and that lobby are worth the $386 versus $298. Book the JW Marriott if you want a reliable, well-rated 4-star on Canal Street for less, with Fogo de Chao downstairs and a slightly higher guest score at 9.1 versus 8.9. Both sit within 0.3km of each other in the same stretch of the CBD/French Quarter edge, so location isn't really the deciding factor here.
The Roosevelt occupies a 1893 building that's been a New Orleans landmark for over a century, its block-long lobby lined with gold leaf ceilings, marble floors and a corridor of chandeliers that runs the length of the building like something out of a Gilded Age fever dream. The Sazerac Bar and the Blue Room have hosted jazz and cocktail culture since the 1930s, all dark wood and brass fittings, and the whole place trades on a sense of old New Orleans money and ceremony. Rooms lean traditional and upholstered rather than sleek, with the kind of heavy drapery and gilt-edged mirrors that suit a hotel built to impress rather than to disappear into the background.
Guests who want the theatre of a historic Southern grand hotel and are willing to pay for the spa and pool.
The JW Marriott sits in a modern Canal Street tower, all large windows and contemporary furnishings rather than antique flourish, with ergonomic workspaces and plush seating pitched at business travellers and steakhouse diners rather than history tourists. The lobby lounge does handcrafted cocktails but skips the theatrical scale of a heritage property, and Fogo de Chao anchors the dining rather than a jazz room. It's a well-run, comfortable chain hotel with no pretensions to being anything else.
Travellers who want a dependable, contemporary room near the action without paying for heritage architecture they won't use.
At $298 the JW Marriott gives up the spa, the hot tub and pet-friendly rooms that the Roosevelt offers, along with the outdoor pool and gym scale that come with a much larger historic property.
The Roosevelt is the more beautiful place to simply stand in, with its gilded lobby corridor and century of jazz-age atmosphere that no contemporary tower can replicate.
| The Roosevelt Hotel New Orleans | JW Marriott New Orleans | |
|---|---|---|
| Price, same night | $401 | $350 |
| Guest rating | 8.9/10 | 9.1/10 |
| Reviews | 647 | 672 |
| Stars | ★★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Facilities on our list | 8 | 5 |
| Distance apart | 309 m |
Nothing on our list that The Roosevelt Hotel New Orleans lacks.
“Our experience at the Roosevelt Hotel was outstanding from the moment we arrived until the moment we reluctantly left.”
“Bruno is absolutely amazing and he accommodated us at the very last minute with rooms and service.”
The Roosevelt's guests come away happier, describing outstanding, near-flawless stays with only a single dining hiccup, while JW Marriott guests praise individual staff but repeatedly note gym, breakfast and construction shortcomings.
“Magic at CHRISTMASTIME! Lovely, year round!”
I don't know what happened with my Christmastime 2025 review, but it never showed up. My husband and I come in to New Orleans a lot from The Mississippi Gulfcoast. My husband is a graduate of Brother Martin H.S., and lived in NOLA so we stay for many functions. He surprised me and booked us at The Roosevelt Christmas 2025. When the doors were thrust open, immediately knew it was going to be quite a magical experience
“Exceptional Stay with One Dining Disappointment”
Our experience at the Roosevelt Hotel was outstanding from the moment we arrived until the moment we reluctantly left. Every staff member treated us with warmth and professionalism, especially Stephen, one of the bellmen, who went above and beyond throughout our stay. He was always courteous, made sure my family never ran out of water, and recommended several restaurants, including Domenica. Unfortunately, Domenica
“Great Getaway to the Roosevelt Hotel”
We just got back from a one night getaway to the beautiful Roosevelt Hotel in New Orleans. The lobby was beautiful, and I had a ball as a history teacher exploring the historical architecture and pieces they had throughout the hotel. The staff were all very friendly, and went above and beyond to make sure all of our needs were met. We stayed in a Luxury King Suite, and it was beyond our expectation. The beds were ex
“We Love Bruno and Justin”
Bruno is absolutely amazing and he accommodated us at the very last minute with rooms and service. Justin was also spectacular. We truly appreciate them stepping in. Will definitely be back!
“Very nice place definitely would stay again. Hopefully construction will be completed”
Very nice
Under construction
“Great hotel-need to fix gym”
The JW is one of my favorite hotels. As we are a Tulane family, we stay there a lot. LOVE the doormen-they are hysterical, friendly and the nicest people. The gym however was disappointing this last time. One half barely had a/c. The 2 Peloton bikes did not work: the seat on one would not stay up (liability for sure) and its pedals were not aligned, the other was not calibrated. I hope they take care of this ASAP as
Luxurious 5-Star Hotel in the Heart of New Orleans Elegant Accommodations and Top-Notch Amenities: Experience stylish rooms with upscale decor, 42-inch flat-screen TVs, and luxurious bathrobes. Enjoy the convenience of a minibar and a 14-inch TV in the bathroom for added comfort. Exceptional Dining and Entertainment Options: Indulge in authentic Italian…
Check-in — · Check-out 12:00 PM
Luxurious Accommodations Indulge in the elegant rooms at JW Marriott New Orleans, boasting large windows, ergonomic workspaces, and plush seating areas. Enjoy modern amenities such as a flat-screen TV, coffee maker, and luxurious bathrobes for a comfortable stay. Dining Excellence Savor a culinary experience at the on-site Fogo de Chao Brazillian…
Check-in — · Check-out 11:00 AM
Rates are live for 2026-10-25, one night, two guests, fetched together so the two are comparable. Facilities and reviews are from each hotel's own listing. The honest take is written by our AI from the listing, the reviews and what is widely known about each hotel. HotelDupe earns a commission if you book, which never changes the verdict. All comparisons